Homemade Apple Pie

Every once in a while I get a hankering for pie—especially a homemade apple pie.  I can’t stand the notion of a store bought or frozen pie and from time to time I’m willing to go through the effort to make one from scratch.

Now baking a pie from scratch takes just a little bit of effort.  It’s not brain surgery, but if you’re like me and don’t do it all the time, it takes a bit of patience and an expectation that what eventually comes out of the oven is going to taste really, really good but it’s look might not be what would win the blue ribbon at the County Fair.  It’ll be just a bit more “rustic” than that.  But who cares as long as it tastes exactly what your taste buds are hungry for.

homemade apple pie fresh from the oven And, your kitchen and whole home are likely to smell just like a little old country granny’s kitchen building a huge expectation of the flavors to come from your homemade apple pie—later, after dinner, after a couple hours of anticipation.  You’ll be able to smell the aromas of the apples and cinnamon and pastry and your mouth will water.

I make a lard crust, but you can make yours with butter or shortening instead.  Lard is the old fashioned way and besides at $1.50 a pound it’s cheaper.  If you prefer, you can use butter or shortening for your “fat” in this crust.  But I think lard makes a flakier, tastier crust.

slice of homemade apple pie

Recipe: Homemade Apple Pie

Summary: Made from scratch pie crust and fresh apples make for a fantastic dessert

Ingredients

  • 2 ¼ cups flour
  • 1 teaspoon salt
  • ¾ cup chilled natural lard
  • 1/3 cup ice water
  • 6-7 tart apples—I used Braeburns
  • ¾ cup brown sugar
  • ¼ cup flour
  • 1 tsp cinnamon (or more)
  • ½ tsp nutmeg (or more)
  • 1 lemon juiced
  • 2 tbsp butter or margarine

Instructions

  • This is what’s called a 2 crust pie. There’s the bottom crust and a crust covering the top.mix the flour and lard
  • Get out a 2 good sized mixing bowls, small bowl and pie pan.
  • For the Crust: Put 2 cups flour and the salt into a mixing bowl. Add the lard. (I keep mine in the freezer and cut ¼ inch thick chunks of it and then cross cut it into small cubes).
  • Cut the lard into the flour and salt with a pastry blender, fork or your fingers until there are flour coated particles about the size of really small peas.
  • In the small bowl combine ¼ cup flour and the water and whisk until smooth. Pour this into the lard/flour mix and stir with a fork just until everything is combined.
  • Reach into the bowl and gather the dough in your hands pressing it together, scrape up the loose stuff that doesn’t stick and press it into the dough.form dough into discs
  • Then divide the dough ball in half (actually make one just a bit bigger) and press each into a disk.
  • Wrap each disk in plastic wrap and put into your freezer for a half hour to an hour until after you make the pie filling.
  • For the filling: Peel the apples. Then cut them into thin slices. I cut each slice in half so I have pieces that are about an inch long, half inch across and a bit more than 1/8 inch thick.apple mix
  • Put the apple slices in the 2nd bowl (or clean out the first bowl and use it again).
  • Add the brown sugar, ¼ cup sugar, cinnamon, nutmeg and lemon juice. (Hint: I also give this 3 or 4 shakes of chipotle powder for a bit of a kick).
  • Mix the apples and dry ingredients together. Let it sit and macerate while you roll your crusts.
  • Build the pie: Get out your pastry board and rolling pin and the larger of the 2 dough disks out and unwrap it. Dust your pastry board and rolling pin with flour.roll out the crust
  • Roll out your pie dough until it is 2 inches larger than the diameter of your pie pan. Do all your rolling from the center of the dough out. And it helps to roll something like roll north, the northeast, then east, etc. You want the crust rolled out evenly about 1/8 inch or little bit more thick.
  • Don’t worry about a split at the edge or a hole in the dough. You’ll be able to “weld” a little piece over it with a piece of excess dough and a bit of water.
  • When rolled out, use a thin bladed spatula to gently lift the dough from the pastry board and fold in half. Transfer it to your pie pan and open up, centering it in the pan.
  • Now you may wish to trim the edge of the dough about ¼ inch larger than the top edge of the pie pan.
  • Roll out your top, fold over and leave it on the pastry board.
  • Start pre-heating your oven to 375.
  • Put the pie pan on a baking/cookie sheet. Pour/scoop the pie filling into the pie fill the pie pan with applespan.
  • Take the 1 tbsp of butter and cut it in little chunks and spread it around the pie filling.
  • Now carefully cover the top of the pie with your second crust. Take the edges of the 2 crusts and roll on top of the pie pan’s edge. Place the tips of the index finger and thumb of one hand on the edge of the crust and use the index finger or thumb of your other hand to press between them to create the flutes in the crust. This is both decorative and functional. But don’t worry if your fluting is less than perfect. This is a homemade pie.pie in the oven
  • Take a paring knife and cut 4 slits in the top of the crust for venting. And lastly, if you want, brush the top of the crust with either milk or egg white and then sprinkle some sugar lightly on the top.
  • Put the pie on the baking sheet in the 375 oven for about 45 minutes. Remove when done and let cool for a minimum of ½-1 hour.

Preparation time: 1 hour(s) homemade apple pie fresh from oven

Cooking time: 45 minute(s)

Number of servings (yield): 6

Culinary tradition: USA (Traditional)

My rating 5 stars:  ★★★★★ 1 review(s)

 That’s a lot of steps, isn’t it?  But it’s worth it.  The taste is fantastic.  The aroma is even better. And, it’s not very expensive—especially compared to buying one at a bakery or even buying and baking a frozen one.

homemade apple pie

The Cheap Bastid Test:  The crust costs about $.50 in ingredients.  The apples were $.77 a pound and I used 1 ¾ lbs. for about $1.40 worth of apples.  Other ingredients like the lemon and brown sugar and butter added about another $.75.  So for a total of $2.65 and about an hour’s worth of prep, I got this homemade beauty of a pie.

That’s the Cheap Bastid Way:  Eat Good. Eat Cheap. Be Grateful!

About Walter Blevins

My wife started to call me Cheap Bastid a while back because I enjoyed coming up with dinners that cost next to nothing--and making them taste good. Yeah, I love to cook. And I love to cook good food cheap. I'm not a chef and I'm definitely not anything close to a gourmet. I'm just a home cook who grew up in a home where cooking was from scratch and was a little bit Midwest and a little bit country. That's because my Mom was from Michigan and my Dad was from Kentucky. I started sharing recipes when my daughter called me in 2006 and asked for my recipe for Swiss Steak. That year for Christmas I put together a cookbook for my 2 kids called "Dad's Everyday Cookbook and Kitchen Survival Guide". And I heard back that they both use it regularly. It was full of basic recipes that I had cooked for them when they were growing up. I work hard at creating recipes that are original and creative and inexpensive. You won't find a foo-foo foodie approach to my recipes and style. I believe that it's OK for food to go up the side of a plate. Food is for eating--it doesn't have to be pretty. And I write about my cooking and my recipes so that I can share them. I hope you enjoy these posts. Leave me a comment--that you liked something or that you didn't, it doesn't matter. I'd love to hear from you.
This entry was posted in baking, Comfort Food, dessert and tagged , , , , , , , , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.